Sallies & Sammies Information

Tucked into a quiet stretch of Hanover, Sallies & Sammies at Sallies & Sammies feels like the kind of neighborhood spot you stumble upon once and then keep coming back to. The location itself is unassuming, but once inside, there’s a welcoming, laid-back diner vibe that immediately puts you at ease. It’s the kind of place where regulars are greeted by name, and newcomers are treated just as warmly.

The menu leans into classic comfort food with a focus on sandwiches, breakfast staples, and simple, satisfying plates done right. Their sammies are clearly the star, stacked generously and served on fresh bread that holds everything together without getting soggy halfway through. One standout is a grilled chicken sandwich with just the right balance of seasoning and juiciness, paired with crisp lettuce and a soft bun that doesn’t overpower the filling. On the breakfast side, the pancakes come out fluffy and golden, and the eggs are cooked exactly as ordered-something that sounds basic but isn’t always guaranteed elsewhere.

What really elevates the experience is the consistency. Reviews from locals often mention how reliable the food and service are, and that lines up with what you notice during a visit. Orders come out in a reasonable time, even when the place gets busy, and the staff checks in just enough without hovering. It feels efficient but still personal, which is a tough balance to strike.

The atmosphere is casual and a bit nostalgic, with simple décor that doesn’t try too hard. It’s not a place you go for a fancy night out, but that’s exactly the appeal. Whether you’re grabbing a quick lunch, meeting friends for coffee, or sitting down for a relaxed weekend breakfast, the setting works without distraction.

Prices are another plus, especially considering portion sizes. You leave feeling like you got real value, not just in quantity but in the quality of the meal. While it may not have an extensive or adventurous menu, what’s offered is clearly thought through and executed with care.

There’s always a bit of subjectivity in any dining experience, and smaller diners like this can vary slightly depending on the day or rush, but overall, the reputation here feels well-earned. It’s the kind of local spot that quietly builds loyalty over time rather than chasing trends, and that shows in both the food and the steady stream of returning customers.

Most Popular Dishes

  • Bottled Soda/Tea $2.75
  • Iced Tea Unsweetened $
  • Bottled Water $2.00
  • Juice $3.00

Orange Juice, Apple Juice

  • Milk $1.50
  • Strawberry Refresher $

Strawberry White Cran Juice with homemade Cream

  • Raspberry Refresher $

Raspberry & Cran Juice with homemade cream

  • Gatorade $3.00

Open Times

Monday 07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Tuesday 07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Wednesday 07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Thursday 07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Friday 07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Saturday 07:00 AM - 03:00 PM

Sunday Closed

Icon

Location & Contact

Contact Details

  • 1010 Eichelberger St, Hanover, PA 17331, United States
  • Right Now :
  • +1 717-698-5061

What People's Say About Place

We were looking for a breakfast place because our usuals are always too crowded. Very welcoming space that is very bright and clean. Fast and friendly service. Affordable prices especially for the high quality of the food. They have ready made pastries so we got those first and they were wonderful especially warmed up. We came for a sit down breakfast. We all got iced teas which we were told were freshly brewed and tasted great. There are many options for customising breakfast sandwiches to your liking. We got our breakfast sandwiches quickly after. The pastries and sandwiches were both excellent. I especially enjoyed my breakfast sandwich on an english muffin which was light and fresh tasting. I also would like to make it known that this spot is very accessible when you get inside. There are wide walkways for a walker or wheelchair to get through and there is also an accessible bathroom with a bar on one side for getting up and down and space to maneuver your mobility device. Overall I would very much recommend this place for anyone looking for a good breakfast or lunch or even a quick coffee. Support local and small owned businesses!

Not only is the staff super friendly, but the food is absolutely delicious! Do yourself a favor and try their soups and do not miss out on their shrimp salad! It is the absolute best! Highly recommend!

This restaurant is incredible. All of the food is top notch and the delightful humans who run it are a breath of fresh air. I come here every time I am in town visiting family at least once, and it's been absolutely wonderful every time. Thank you so much for everything you do for the local community.

My mother and I dined here for the first time this week. We both ordered from the Sallie menu (salads). We both wanted the Cobb, but they only had enough chicken prepared for one salad. I instead opted for the Three Star Sallie. It was topped with chicken salad, tuna salad and shrimp salad. I liked it very much. My mother didn't enjoy her Cobb. She tells me that the chicken had a rubbery texture. Their Sammies looked good (on other patrons plates, lol).

Amazing place that has quickly become a favorite! So many great options to choose from! the chicken& black bean quesadilla is my #1 choice, shrimp salad on lobster roll was good, and my friend got the Cuban. Quiche is warm, mealty, and perfect! I love the iced americano adding cold foam & their lattes are delicious! Everything is so good! Highly recommend

Had the chicken salad sammie here last week. Sandwich was delicious and the place was very clean and atmosphere was nice and laid back. The lady who took my order was very friendly and professional. Definitely will be back to try some more of their food.

This is an awesome place. I go there at least once a week. The owners are wonderful. Everything thing on the menu is delicious. The atmosphere there is relaxing. The shaved pastrami pita is the bomb!

Sallies and Sammies had fast and friendly service. It had a great atmosphere with beautiful decor. The amazing lady serving us was very helpful and polite. She even helped us with picking out flooring! The food was great and so was the coffee. She gave us our coffee in a spooky cup with marshmallow ghost! 10/10 would recommend to anyone! We are already planning our next trip!

Places Nearby